Friday, March 2, 2012

Bugzilla Post4

Bugzilla vs. Jira


Bugzilla

Jira

Basic

Open source

Commercial license

Server-Side Architecture includes Perl and MySQL

Server-Side Architecture includes Java (J2EE), MySQL, Tomcat and Lucene

Pros: Bugzilla

Server Load is low. Because the Perl scripts act as simple Common Gateway Interfaces and can be highly sped up with mod_perl. On large databases the database may become the bottleneck when doing search queries.

Server Load is considerable compared to Bugzilla. Because JIRA is a more complex system and typically executes a whole lot more of the server side code per web request

Has a very high security due to full open source code revelation and usage by Mozilla and some other big player.

Compared to Bugzilla, JIRA security risks are somewhat higher due to the larger overall complexity.

Supports security groups which are quite flexible, but a bit complex feature for grouping users & issues and granting permissions.

Has simpler permissions model which is straighter and possibly more appropriate.

Has a quite powerful advanced search features.

JIRA lacks some of the expert level search conditions that Bugzilla can do and searching for text in JIRA issues may be limited by how Lucene index works.

Pros: Jira

Has not considered much about developing its user interface over years.

Provides a far better user interface than Bugzilla.

Custom field types available in Bugzilla are Text fields, Multi-selection, Drop-down, Date/time, Bug ID

Custom field types available in Jira are Text fields, Number fields, Multi-selection, URL fields, Group pickers, Labels, Multi Checkboxes, Date/time, Multi User Pickers and many more than Bugzilla

No comments:

Post a Comment